The "I've Read a Few Classics and I'm Ready for More" Starter Pack
Part 2: 15 More Books for When the First List Worked
The original Starter Pack post hit 2,506 likes.
The comment section immediately told me exactly what I got wrong.
“Disappointed at no Count of Monte Cristo mention,” wrote one reader. “My current read and my goodness is it enjoyable and easy to get into for a classic.” That comment got 42 likes. Forty-two people liked a comment about a book I didn’t include. Message received.
Part 2 is for readers who finished one or two books from the original list, felt the click of something working, and are now standing in front of their bookshelves asking: okay, what’s next?
Same format. Same categories. Slightly higher difficulty — not the Boss Level, not yet, but you are no longer a beginner and the books reflect that. You have built some tolerance for nineteenth century prose. You know now that “slow” and “boring” are not the same thing. You are ready.
Fifteen books. Five categories. Let’s go.
A Note on Difficulty
The original list was Level 1. This is Level 2.
What that means practically: some of these are longer. Some have more complex structures. Some require a little more patience in the first fifty pages before they open up. None of them require a PhD. All of them are worth the investment.
If a book from this list defeats you, that is not failure. That is information. Put it down, read something from the original list, and come back. The book will wait.
Category 1: THE ONE EVERYONE ASKED FOR (Start Here If You’re Not Sure Where to Start)
1. The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas
Page count: 1,276 pages (unabridged) — or 500 pages in the abridged Penguin edition, which is perfectly acceptable
Reading time: 12-15 hours unabridged / 8-10 hours abridged
Why it’s more accessible than it looks:
It is a revenge thriller. That’s it. That is the entire plot. A man is wrongly imprisoned for fourteen years, escapes, finds a fortune, and systematically destroys every person who put him there. Dumas was writing for a newspaper serialization, which means every single chapter ends with a reason to keep reading. He was physically incapable of writing a boring chapter because his readers would have stopped paying for the newspaper.
What you get:
The greatest revenge plot in literary history
Prison escapes and hidden treasure
Elaborate schemes executed across decades
A protagonist who becomes so rich and powerful he is essentially a Bond villain with better taste
Genuinely satisfying payoffs for every single setup
The catch:
The unabridged version has a lot of characters and several subplots. The abridged Penguin Classic cuts the slower subplots and keeps the main revenge arc. Start with abridged if the page count intimidates you. Upgrade to unabridged once you are invested.
Read this if you like: Any revenge narrative, Succession, The Talented Mr. Ripley, anything where a wronged person takes years to settle the score
Why it matters: Every modern revenge story owes this book a debt. The structure of the long-game, the patience of the setup, the satisfaction of the payoff — Dumas invented the template in 1844 and nobody has improved on it.
Bonus: The 2002 film with Jim Caviezel is a very good abridged version for the basic plot. Watch it after, not before.
42 people asked for this in the comments. They were right.
Category 2: SHORT CLASSICS (Still Under 300 Pages — You Can Do This)
2. Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton
Page count: 96 pages
Reading time: 2-3 hours
Why it’s accessible:
It is shorter than most short story collections. Wharton’s prose is clean and precise — nowhere near as dense as James or Hardy. You can read this in an afternoon.
What you get:
A New England farmer trapped in a loveless marriage
His wife’s cousin arrives
Everyone is repressed
The ending is the most quietly devastating thing Wharton ever wrote, which is saying something because Wharton made a career of devastating endings
The catch:
It is bleak. Relentlessly, specifically bleak. If you need your 96 pages to end happily, this is not your 96 pages.
Read this if you like: The Awakening, any story about people trapped by circumstance and their own inability to act
Why it matters: Wharton strips the classic tragic novel down to its skeleton. This is what happens when a writer who usually needs 400 pages decides to do it in 96. Nothing is wasted. Every sentence is load-bearing.
96 pages. One of the bleakest endings in American fiction. Wharton is not sorry.
3. The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
Page count: 64 pages (it’s a short story, technically)
Reading time: 1-2 hours
Why it’s accessible:
First person. Present tense. You are inside the narrator’s head from page one. The prose is immediate and readable and pulls you along whether you want to go or not.
What you get:
A woman is confined to a room by her doctor husband to treat her “nervous condition”
She becomes fixated on the yellow wallpaper in the room
She begins to see a woman inside the pattern
The ending is one of the most discussed scenes in American literature
The catch:
It is psychological horror. Not gore — psychological. The discomfort is the point.
Read this if you like: Shirley Jackson, Gothic fiction, any story about a woman being told she is imagining things when she is not
Why it matters: Gilman wrote this in 1892 based on her own experience of the “rest cure” prescribed to women with postpartum depression. Her doctor told her to do no intellectual work and pursue no stimulation. She wrote this story instead. Her doctor later said the story made him change his treatment approach. That is the most satisfying author’s note in literary history.
She was prescribed rest and no intellectual stimulation. She wrote this instead. Her doctor changed his practice. Gilman wins.
Category 3: PAGE-TURNERS (Harder Than the First List, Still Impossible to Put Down)
4. Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte
Page count: 532 pages
Reading time: 10-12 hours
Why it’s accessible:
First person narrative, clear chronological structure, a protagonist who talks to you directly and has opinions about everything. Jane is one of the most readable Victorian narrators ever written because she is never performing intelligence — she is simply thinking out loud, and her thoughts are always interesting.
What you get:
Orphan girl survives terrible childhood, becomes a governess
Falls in love with her mysterious employer Rochester
A secret in the attic that changes everything
Jane making a moral choice that costs her everything and being right about it
One of the most satisfying endings in Victorian fiction
The catch:
There is a significant Gothic middle section that some readers find slow. It is not slow. It is atmosphere. Give it the pages it needs.
Read this if you like: Gothic romance, any story about a woman who refuses to compromise herself, Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier
Why it matters: Charlotte Bronte created a template for the self-possessed female narrator that every writer after her has been working with. Jane is not waiting to be saved. She saves herself, specifically, and on her own terms, and Bronte was radical about it.
Jane Eyre is the original “I will not shrink for you.” Written in 1847. Still current.
5. Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier
Page count: 449 pages
Reading time: 8-10 hours
Why it’s accessible:
Du Maurier writes like a dream. The prose pulls you forward without effort. The atmosphere is total from the first paragraph. This is the definition of a page-turner that also happens to be literature.
What you get:
Unnamed narrator marries a wealthy widower named Maxim de Winter
They move into Manderley, his grand estate
The shadow of his first wife Rebecca is everywhere
Mrs. Danvers, the housekeeper, who is terrifying
A mystery that turns into something stranger and darker than you expect
The catch:
The first chapter tells you Manderley is gone. Du Maurier doesn’t hide that the ending is bad. The pleasure is figuring out how it got there.
Read this if you like: Gone Girl, any psychological thriller, The Silent Patient, anything where you’re not sure you can trust the narrator
Why it matters: Du Maurier invented several of the thriller conventions we now take for granted: the unreliable narrator driven by insecurity, the perfect dead woman as antagonist, the house as psychological landscape. Published in 1938. Still outsells most modern thrillers.
The first line is “Last night I dreamt I went to Manderley again.” You will not put it down.
6. The Count of Monte Cristo is in Category 1 because it deserved its own category.
Category 4: EMOTIONALLY ACCESSIBLE (Human Emotion Is Universal — Still True at Level 2)
7. Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte
Page count: 342 pages
Reading time: 7-8 hours
Why it’s accessible:
Once you understand that Heathcliff is not a romantic hero but a man who was humiliated as a child and spent thirty years making everyone around him pay for it, the whole novel snaps into focus and becomes very difficult to put down.
What you get:
Catherine Earnshaw, who loves Heathcliff and marries someone else for money
Heathcliff, who never forgives her or anyone connected to her
Two generations of families destroyed
The moors
One of the most analyzed relationships in English literature
The catch:
The narrative structure is unusual — it’s told by a housekeeper, relayed to a tenant, looking back in time. Give it thirty pages to orient yourself and then it flows.
Read this if you like: Toxic love stories, revenge narratives, anything set on dramatic landscapes
Why it matters: Emily Bronte wrote one novel. One. This is it. She died the year after it was published at thirty years old. The novel was considered immoral and disturbing by Victorian critics. It is now assigned in every secondary school in England.
She wrote one novel and it was this. Emily Bronte had opinions about how to spend your one contribution.
8. Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy
Page count: 864 pages
Reading time: 18-20 hours
Why it’s accessible:
Tolstoy writes with the clarity of someone who needs you to understand him. No deliberate obscurity. No showing off. He wants you inside his characters’ heads and he puts you there efficiently. For 864 pages this is remarkably unintimidating prose.
What you get:
Anna, a married woman in St. Petersburg society, has an affair
Society destroys her for it
Her husband does fine
The man she left everything for gradually moves on
A parallel story about Levin, a landowner figuring out how to live, which is Tolstoy working out his own philosophy in fiction
The catch:
The Levin sections are slower than the Anna sections. They are also where Tolstoy puts everything he actually believed. Read them. They pay off.
Read this if you like: Any story about society’s double standards for men and women, long immersive novels you can live inside for weeks
Why it matters: “All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.” That is the first sentence. Tolstoy tells you exactly what he is writing before you turn the first page and he delivers on it for 864 pages.
She did nothing her husband wasn’t also doing. He got to keep his life. Tolstoy wrote 864 pages to make sure you noticed the difference.
9. A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens
Page count: 489 pages
Reading time: 9-11 hours
Why it’s accessible:
Dickens was writing for a serialized magazine audience who would stop paying if he got boring. He did not get boring. This is the most plot-driven Dickens novel and the one most likely to make you forget you are reading something from 1859.
What you get:
London and Paris during the French Revolution
A lawyer who drinks himself into oblivion because he has decided he is worthless
A woman who knits names into fabric and waits
A man who looks exactly like someone else, which becomes very important
The most famous opening sentence in the English language and a closing line that earns it
The catch:
The first 50 pages are setup-heavy. Stick with it. By the trial scene you will not be able to stop.
Read this if you like: Historical fiction, the Count of Monte Cristo, any story where a single act of sacrifice carries the entire weight of the plot
Why it matters: “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.” Everyone knows the opening. Almost no one has read the ending that justifies it. The ending is Sydney Carton walking toward something and thinking something, and it is one of the great closing images in English fiction, and you have to read the whole novel to understand why it lands the way it does.
“It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done.” He meant it. Dickens made sure you believed him. Read it.
Category 5: SURPRISINGLY FUN AT LEVEL 2 (Still Enjoyable — Now With More Layers)
10. North and South by Elizabeth Gaskell
Page count: 544 pages
Reading time: 10-12 hours
Why it’s accessible:
It is Pride and Prejudice but with industrial labor politics and a heroine who argues about economics. If that sounds dull, you have not met Margaret Hale yet. She is one of the most satisfying protagonists in Victorian fiction.
What you get:
Margaret moves from the rural south of England to a grim industrial northern mill town
She clashes with mill owner John Thornton, who she finds arrogant
He proposes. She turns him down.
She is wrong about him. He is wrong about her.
The obstacles between them involve a labor strike, a death, a misunderstanding, and a train station
The ending is extremely satisfying
The catch:
The middle section dealing with the labor strike is dense with Victorian industrial politics. It is also the best part of the novel once you get inside it.
Read this if you like: Pride and Prejudice, any enemies-to-lovers where both characters have to actually grow, the BBC adaptation (2004, Richard Armitage, watch it immediately after)
Why it matters: Gaskell wrote about industrial poverty and workers’ rights with the same seriousness Dickens did and got a third of the recognition because she was a woman. North and South is the corrective. Margaret Hale is arguing about labor rights and refusing marriage proposals in 1855. She would be fine today.
“Look back at me.” The BBC adaptation. Trust me. Read the book first.
11. Middlemarch by George Eliot
Page count: 904 pages
Reading time: 18-22 hours
Why it’s accessible:
George Eliot (real name Mary Ann Evans, who published under a male pseudonym because Victorian England) writes with warmth and specificity and a quality that is rare in long novels: she genuinely likes her characters, even the difficult ones, and that affection makes 900 pages feel manageable.
What you get:
A small English town in the 1830s, multiple interlocking stories
Dorothea Brooke, who marries the wrong man on purpose because she thinks suffering is noble
Tertius Lydgate, a doctor whose ambitions are slowly strangled by circumstance
Fred Vincy, who needs to grow up, and the woman who has been waiting patiently for him to do so
The most accurate depiction of a bad marriage in Victorian fiction
The catch:
It is 900 pages and it starts slowly. The first 100 pages are setup. After that it is impossible to leave.
Read this if you like: Long immersive novels about ordinary lives, Tolstoy, any story where the most interesting character is not the one making the biggest choices
Why it matters: Virginia Woolf called it “one of the few English novels written for grown-up people.” It is a novel about the difficulty of living well in a world that is not organized around your particular gifts. Most people find it more personally devastating the older they get when they read it.
“Her full nature spent itself in channels which had no great name on the earth.” That last line. It takes 900 pages to earn it. It earns it.
12. Three Men in a Boat by Jerome K. Jerome
Page count: 182 pages
Reading time: 3-4 hours
Why it’s accessible:
It is a comedy. Written in 1889. Still funny. Legitimately, reliably, out-loud funny. This is one of the least-assigned and most underrated classics in the English language and the reason is that it is not miserable and therefore people do not take it seriously as literature.
What you get:
Three men (and a dog named Montmorency) take a boating holiday on the Thames
They are collectively incompetent
Jerome narrates their failures with perfect comic timing
There are digressions about cheese, tin openers, and the proper way to pack a bag that remain the funniest extended prose sequences in Victorian literature
The catch:
There is not one. It is just funny. That is the whole thing.
Read this if you like: P.G. Wodehouse, dry British humor, any book that makes you laugh on public transport and then have to explain yourself
Why it matters: Jerome proved in 1889 that a novel could be comic and literary simultaneously, that the two things were not in opposition, and that a book about three idiots on a boat could outlast most serious literature of the same decade. Most of the serious literature of 1889 is forgotten. This is reprinted every year.
It is about three men and a dog on a boat. It is in the top ten funniest books in English. These two sentences are both true.
Category 6: MODERN CLASSICS THAT FEEL IMMEDIATELY CURRENT
13. 1984 by George Orwell
Page count: 328 pages
Reading time: 6-8 hours
Why it’s accessible:
Orwell writes with political journalist clarity — no unnecessary complexity, no showing off, prose designed to be understood. The world-building is total but efficient. You are inside Oceania by page ten.
What you get:
Winston Smith lives in a totalitarian state where the government controls language, history, and thought
He begins a forbidden affair and a quiet private rebellion
He meets O’Brien, who seems like an ally
Room 101
The ending, which is not the ending people who haven’t read it expect
The catch:
The middle section includes a long political treatise called “The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism.” You need to read it. It is where Orwell puts his actual argument about power.
Read this if you like: Any dystopian fiction, The Handmaid’s Tale, anything about surveillance and state control
Why it matters: Orwell is not issuing a warning about what might happen. He is showing you, in precise mechanical steps, how a person’s interior life gets dismantled from the outside until nothing original remains. Most people learn the political allegory in school and miss the technology. The technology is the whole lesson.
“He loved Big Brother.” That is the last sentence. That is what the Party wanted and got. That is the horror.
14. Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston
Page count: 193 pages
Reading time: 4-5 hours
Why it’s accessible:
Hurston writes in the vernacular of her characters and it sings. The prose is musical and immediate and once you settle into the dialect in the first chapter it reads faster than almost anything on this list.
What you get:
Janie Crawford’s story, told looking back: three marriages, three different kinds of love, one that nearly destroys her
The Florida moors and the Harlem Renaissance community Hurston documented
A woman figuring out, at forty, that she has been living for other people’s definitions of her life
One of the most beautiful and heartbreaking final lines in American literature
The catch:
The dialect takes about twenty pages to find your rhythm with. Do not skip it or read a “modernized” edition. The voice is the whole point.
Read this if you like: The Awakening, any coming-of-age story about a woman finding herself after loss, lyrical prose
Why it matters: Hurston was a Harlem Renaissance writer who was largely forgotten after her death and rediscovered by Alice Walker in the 1970s. She died in poverty and was buried in an unmarked grave. Walker found the grave and put a marker on it. The novel was rescued. These things are connected. The book is about a woman who refused to be defined by anyone else’s story, written by a woman who nearly disappeared from literary history entirely.
Hurston was buried in an unmarked grave. Alice Walker found it and put a headstone on it. The book was almost lost. It was not lost. Read it.
15. The Odyssey by Homer (Emily Wilson translation)
Page count: 592 pages
Reading time: 10-12 hours
Why it’s accessible:
The Emily Wilson translation, published in 2017 and the first translation of The Odyssey by a woman, reads like a contemporary novel. Clean, direct, fast-moving. Wilson strips away the archaisms that make other translations feel like homework.
What you get:
Odysseus trying to get home after the Trojan War for ten years
Monsters, gods, a cyclops, Sirens, the underworld, a sorceress who turns men into pigs
His wife Penelope at home, holding off suitors for twenty years through pure strategic intelligence
His son Telemachus becoming a man in his father’s absence
One of the oldest stories in Western literature, still immediate
The catch:
The episodic structure (each adventure is fairly self-contained) means some sections move faster than others. The Penelope sections are, arguably, more interesting than the Odysseus sections once you are reading for what the poem is actually doing.
Read this if you like: Fantasy and adventure, any epic story about trying to get back to where you belong, mythology
Why it matters: Three thousand years old. Still the template for every “hero’s journey” story ever written. Homer structured it so that Odysseus, the man of many tricks, keeps outwitting everyone — and Penelope, at home, is doing exactly the same thing and nobody is writing an epic about her. Wilson noticed this. Her translation makes sure you notice it too.
Get the Emily Wilson translation. It reads like it was written last year. That is the highest compliment you can give a three-thousand-year-old poem.
How to Level Up from Here
You have now completed Level 1 and Level 2. Here is where you go next.
Level 3 (you are ready for this after the above):
War and Peace (Tolstoy — longer than Anna Karenina but the same readable clarity)
Les Misérables (Hugo — get a good translation; the Fahnestock and MacAfee is the most readable)
Middlemarch (already on this list — if you saved it, now is the time)
Don Quixote (Edith Grossman translation — Cervantes is funnier than you think)
Level 4 (Boss Fight — do not start here):
Ulysses by James Joyce (read a companion guide first, specifically the Gifford annotations)
In Search of Lost Time by Proust (seven volumes; start with Lydia Davis’s translation of Swann’s Way)
Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace (technically modern but structurally the most demanding novel in American English)
You would not run a marathon without training. You have been training. The Boss Level will still be there when you are ready.
Which One Are You Starting With?
Drop a comment:
Have you read any of these?
Which one from the original list did you finish?
Which one on this list looks least intimidating?
Are you a Count of Monte Cristo person or a Wuthering Heights person? (These are different personality types and I will be respectfully judging your answer.)
If you want a personalized reading order based on where you are right now — what you’ve already read, what you loved, what defeated you, and what you actually have time for — that is exactly what the Custom 12-Month Reading Plan is for. Details below.
This month in the Literary Fancy members archive:
A live workshop recording: Rewire Your Brain With Dead Authors. Sixty minutes of neuroscience, a five-step protocol, and the research on why your attention span broke and how to get it back.
A brand new 30-day reading guide for The Woman in White. Count Fosco. A woman declared legally dead. A villain who is somehow also charming. Twenty pages a day. Yours immediately on subscribing.
The Unhinged Classics Reading Roadmap at 95 books across 11 parts. The complete version. Not the public one.
New literary phone wallpapers. Dark. Gold. Opinionated lockscreen energy.
Plus every members-only post, monthly freebies, the private chat, and access to a full archive you get on Day One.
$10 a month. Less than a paperback.
Support the Newsletter
Buy me a coffee on Ko-fi. Tolstoy had a large estate and a wife who copied War and Peace by hand seven times. I have a laptop, six children, and a full-time job in financial services marketing. The coffee is doing significant structural work.
Shop the digital guides: the Complete Unhinged Classics Roadmap, the War and Peace Companion Guide, and Custom 12-Month Reading Plans.
Share this post with the person in your life who finished something from the original list and immediately asked what to read next. You know exactly who they are.
Still reading. Still here. Don’t tell my kids.
Karen
The 2024 mini-series version of "The Count of Monte Cristo" which was shown on the PBS show "Masterpiece Theater" is very good and more faithful to the book than most movie versions.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt29547746/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_0_tt_8_nm_0_in_0_q_the%20count%20of
I've read most of these! Will definitely try Three Men in a Boat.
I don't understand how you assume a reading pace of around 50 pages an hour! For me it's maybe 30.