The Dark Side of Classic Literature Nobody Talks About
What’s hiding in your favorite classic books?
📚 Classic books are celebrated for their timeless wisdom.
😬 But they also have some outdated, uncomfortable truths.
🧐 Let’s dig into the hidden flaws nobody warns you about.
The Dark Side of Classic Literature Nobody Talks About
Classic literature is often described as the “best of the best.” We’re told these books are full of wisdom, timeless truths, and unforgettable stories. But what we’re not told—at least not often—is that some of these books have a dark side. Beneath the fancy language and deep themes, you’ll find things that might make you cringe, scratch your head, or even feel a little angry.
Let’s talk about it.
The Problem of Representation
A lot of classic books were written in times when the world was very different. Back then, people’s views on race, gender, and class weren’t exactly fair. Many books reflect those outdated attitudes.
Take The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain, for example. This book is considered one of the great American novels, and for good reason—it takes a critical look at slavery and racism. But it also uses language and stereotypes that can make readers today feel uncomfortable. While Twain meant to expose the wrongs of his time, the way he did it can still sting.
Or think about The Merchant of Venice by Shakespeare. It’s a famous play, but the way it portrays Shylock, a Jewish character, has been called out for being anti-Semitic. Sure, it was written over 400 years ago, but does that make it okay?
These books give us a snapshot of their time, but they also remind us how far we’ve come—and how far we still need to go.
The Unrealistic Expectations
Have you ever read a romance in a classic book and thought, “This doesn’t feel right”? That’s because many of these stories set impossible standards for love and relationships.
Take Mr. Rochester from Jane Eyre, my all-time favorite. At first glance, he seems like the ultimate romantic hero. He’s brooding, mysterious, and full of secrets. But let’s not forget—he keeps his wife locked in the attic! That’s not exactly #RelationshipGoals.
Or look at Romeo and Juliet. We’re supposed to see them as star-crossed lovers who couldn’t live without each other. But if you think about it, they barely knew each other, and their story is more about impulsive decisions than true love. Is that really a romance we should look up to?
These unrealistic portrayals can make us question what’s “normal” in relationships. They also remind us that we shouldn’t base our own lives on fictional characters.
The Trauma Nobody Mentions
Another thing people don’t talk about is how emotionally intense some classic books are. These stories deal with heavy topics like death, betrayal, and loss, and they don’t always handle them in a way that feels supportive.
Take Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. The ending is heartbreaking and leaves you with a sinking feeling in your stomach. I couldn’t stop thinking about it for days. Or consider The Great Gatsby. It’s full of lies, heartbreak, and tragedy, and by the end, you’re left wondering if anyone in the book was truly happy.
When you’re young or not ready for these themes, they can hit hard. Nobody warns you about the emotional toll some of these books take. It’s okay to feel overwhelmed, and it’s okay to take a break from reading them.
The Glorification of Misery
Have you noticed how many classics focus on suffering? Sure, struggle is a part of life, and these books are often trying to show us something meaningful. But sometimes, it feels like they romanticize misery.
For example, in Les Misérables by Victor Hugo, nearly every character is hit with wave after wave of tragedy. While the story is powerful, it can leave readers wondering: Is life supposed to be this hopeless?
Or take Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë. Heathcliff and Catherine’s toxic relationship is often celebrated as passionate and romantic, but if you dig deeper, it’s just plain unhealthy.
When books like these are held up as masterpieces, it’s easy to think that suffering is somehow noble or necessary to live a meaningful life. But is that the message we want to take away?
What Can We Learn From the Dark Side?
So why should we bother reading these books if they have so many issues? For one thing, they challenge us. They make us think about the past and how it shaped the present. They help us see how far we’ve come as a society—and remind us how much further we still need to go.
Take Uncle Remus: His Songs and Sayings by Joel Chandler Harris. The stories themselves are beautifully crafted and rooted in African American oral traditions, but the book also carries the weight of being written during a time when racial stereotypes were widely accepted. To us today, those stereotypes are harmful and wrong, but they reflect the era in which Harris lived.
It’s important to read these books critically. Just because something is a “classic” doesn’t mean it’s perfect. It’s okay to question what you’re reading, to disagree with the author, or to see flaws in their work.
At the same time, we can’t expect people in the past to think like people today. Authors wrote within the norms and biases of their time. While it’s fair to critique their views, it’s also worth appreciating what their work tells us about history—both its beauty and its brokenness.
At the end of the day, classic literature is like a mirror. It shows us the good, the bad, and the ugly parts of humanity. And sometimes, looking into that mirror can help us better understand ourselves and our world.
Final Thoughts
Classic literature isn’t just about dusty old books on a shelf. It’s about understanding the stories that shaped us—and being brave enough to question them. When we look at the dark side of these stories, we’re not just tearing them down. We’re learning from them and growing as readers and thinkers.
So the next time someone hands you a classic and tells you it’s the greatest book ever written, take a closer look. There might be more to the story than meets the eye.
Join the Literary Fancy Book Club - New Book Starting Dec 1st.
Want to read Les Miserables with a community? Join the Literary Fancy Book Club for December and January, where we’ll explore Hugo’s masterpiece together! Book plan starts on Dec 1st.
As a paid subscriber, you’ll enjoy:
Reading Plans to keep you on track
Companion Guides with themes, context, and character insights
Quizzes + Vocabulary Guides to deepen your understanding
Exclusive Substack Chat + Live Discussions to connect with fellow readers
Start your journey with us and experience Les Miserables like never before. Subscribe here for all the resources, community, and guidance you need to bring Hugo’s words to life.
Let’s dive into the heart and soul of literature together!
Since I’m all about helping you become the best reader you can be, I’ve got a couple of freebies for you too:
🎁 25 AI Prompts to Become a Better Reader: Want to read more, understand deeper, and connect with books in a new way? These prompts will help you reflect, analyze, and grow as a reader.
🎁 Notion Template of My Favorite Female-Empowering Fictional Reads: I’ve compiled a list of must-read books featuring fierce female leads who will inspire you, empower you, and make you cheer out loud. Perfect for your next empowering readathon!
📚Literary Fancy is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.